Indigenous Leaders Are Pissed About BAAJA

Indigenous Leaders Are Pissed About BAAJA
Photograph by Alisa Petrosova / Website

Support my work and upgrade to paid here for as little as $5 a month. I will be moving to Substack very soon, so please keep an eye out for subscription updates!


LISTENING: to some harry styles, who was robbed of grammy noms!
FEELING: a little stuffed after a quesadilla
SEEING: a cute thrift store across the street I want to pop into!

As I write this, Senate Democrats just fumbled their only opportunity to stop the GOP-backed Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA, for short. The bill is meant to accelerate timelines for projects like data centers, windmills, pipelines, and even detention centers. Democratic proponents argue the bill would allow them to make renewable energy development happen faster — but at what cost?

On Wednesday, an upper chamber of Congress pushed BAAJA forward despite outcries from their constituents, namely Indigenous peoples who are concerned about how the bill's permitting reforms threaten their sovereignty rights over projects on their lands. Tribal nations and Indigenous groups are supposed to have government-to-government relationships with the U.S., yet federal elected officials failed to adequately consult with them. Should BAAJA pass as is, the few rights and legal tools tribes have will be gutted.

Suzette Brewer at Native News Online has the most comprehensive reporting I could find on this intersection. She writes:

On the night of September 30, 2026, phones across Indian Country began lighting up with alerts and frantic text messages. Late that afternoon, the Senate had dropped the 400-page Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA). A sweeping reform bill, its sponsors say it would speed approval and permitting of energy and infrastructure projects, expand electric transmission and help lower energy costs. 

But for Tribes and preservation advocates, the bill contained a number of poison pills that would put their sovereignty and lands at risk. At issue: Title III of the bill would amend Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, the provision that requires federal agencies to consider a project’s effects on historic properties and consult with Tribes when places of religious or cultural significance to them may be affected. 

The National Historic Preservation Act is an essential line of defense for Indigenous peoples in the U.S. Across Turtle Island, settlers have long disregarded Indigenous history in their decision-making. Even Trump's latest expansion of the U.S.-Mexico border wall disrupted the remains of Native American ancestors. Imagine what the administration and industry could get away with if they had an even weaker set of environmental and preservation laws.

On the National Historic Preservation Act, Native American Rights Fund senior attorney Wesley Furlong told Amelia Schaifer at ICT: "There is no other law that has allowed tribes a seat at the table like this to ensure that they are informing decision-making and protecting their sacred places. This bill wipes that away and entirely removes tribes from this process, and removes any thought that Tribal and Indigenous values are important or should be considered in federal decision-making. It’s a real step backward in the federal government’s relationship to tribes."

Several national organizations representing Indigenous peoples have stepped out to oppose the bill: the National Congress of American Indians, Affiliated Tribes of Northwest Indians, and Great Plains Tribal Chairman’s Association, just to name a few. The Coalition of Large Tribes, however, has been an active participant in shaping the bill, prompting the Northern Arapaho Tribe to withdraw from the group.

There's still a chance that legislators will amend the bill's language to put Indigenous sovereignty at the center before the final text moves to the president's desk.

I'm always down for clean and renewable energy but not like this. I trust the voices of the frontlines to guide us toward the right path. When Indigenous leaders tell us to be cautious, we need to listen. And they're not alone. Many leading environmental groups are against the bill, too. I trust the experts.

Plus, BAAJA is yet another blueprint from Project 2025. Anything that pushes that agenda is a red flag in my book. 🌀

Currently Reading

Rachel Ramirez has the conservation story you've gotta read this week in Vox. She also has a hot take on BAAJA in High Country News, focused on the Salish Sea communities' opposition.

Bianca Fortis has a powerful investigation published in The Margin about how AI is helping fuel even more disaster fraud than we already had.

I love seeing the work Nina Lakhani is doing for Drilled. Her latest is a series called Displaced, or Desplazado in Spanish, looking at the communities displaced by climate disaster across Latin America.

This Washington Post story by Brianna Sacks about a 27-year-old who died fighting a wildfire that he shouldn't have been anywhere near absolutely gutted me.

An insane feature by Matt Viser in The Atlantic about the Prairieland case where one man is serving 30 years for moving a box of zines: "I figured something really bad must have been in that box, and I just hadn’t seen it yet. Or, alternatively, that Sanchez must have had some bigger role in the events than what had been reported. But I found no hidden explanation for what had happened to him. As best as I could establish, Sanchez is set to spend the next 30 years in prison simply for moving a box of radical zines."

Poetry

WALKING AMONG THE DEAD
today, I walked among the dead
the grass was freshly cut,
and the crickets sang

I wonder if in these trees the bats roost overhead,
gentle giants, guarding the eternal slumber of the dead

reid, rogers, kremer, light
these are the names on stones
I wonder what fueled their fight

dandelions sprout from their graves
a lawnmower roars, feeding from the soil beds
not even the weeds or grass are safe
we each have our day

-ylf-

I'll be moving this to Substack very soon, which will affect the pricing for paid subscribers. There are fewer tier options there, so please be prepared and look out for those updates!

- Yessenia x

Yessenia Funes

Yessenia Funes

Yessenia Funes is an environmental journalist telling stories of society's most oppressed. She's been published in The Guardian, Yale Climate Connections, The Verge, Vox, and more. Think of this newsletter as a digital postcard from a friend.
NYC